Which GS is better?

[truely false]

Please, can anyone help with this. I was wondering which GS is better and Why?

1
Forcium GS of Deathblow
Crit Dmg 32%
Amp 42%
http://img252.imageshack.us/img252/4273/gs1l.jpg
My P Server Item

or

2
Forcium GS of Deathblow
Crit Dmg 80%
Amp 14%
http://img818.imageshack.us/img818/8248/47365031.jpg
My Offical NA Server Item

[modem]

the 2nd one is better

[xXxGearsoftsxXx]

i'll go for 2 option:)

[Davynelord]

Option 2 looks good because of the CD...but honestly, it depends on what level are both GS and what your other stats are...42% from just weapons could be massive because if your other stats are high also (the higher the better), the amp would likely boost your crit damage by more than what the 76% CDi on the 2nd weapon would....or maybe not...but can't tell without knowing the other stats your working with.


Ok, plugged them into my damage chart....keep in mind I don't know the levels of the weapons so this assumes they are both +0.....and I used 950 base attack for the calculations...this is just using the stats of both weapons, not extra stats from your other gear.




Skill = 10% amp
Base Damage
SKill = 10% Amp
Crit Damage
SKill = 95% amp
Base Damage

Skill = 95% amp
Crit Damage



Option 1
1564.00
2064.48
2371.50
3130.38


Option 2
1298.00
2287.48
2105.50
3705.68


Best Dmg
Option 1 does 266 more than Option 2
Option 2 does 223 more than Option 1
Option 1 266 more than Option 2
Option 2 does 575.30 more than Option 1






Again, The stats of the rest of your gear will change the actual damage done, but the ratio of damage will remain the same between the two weapons so as long as both weapons are equal level...this is because when you add stats (amp, base attack or CD) to one, the same stats should be applied to the other....this is just a rough estimate, a reference if you will...no way I can come up with exact damages unless I know your full stats.

[Andrea]

and what ur cr is...

what baffles me is how u can get the stats in option 2? care to show a screenie? been under the impression that it's either 72 or 80 cd off of pc dmg (with 0 amp) or if u wanna go for one slot 14 amp with pc dmg, best u can get is 56 cd extended.

Or u happen to have a 2 slot pc dmg with amp in one slot? man, epic! then u only have 52 cd but 80 cd potential (which may never be realized due to the scarcity of sehh). screenshot pls or it doesn't exist lol.

this is forcium and not lycan, k.

[USB-11]

Does that kind of weapons actually exist? That's over exaggerate stats for being a fc.

[Museifu]

The first one is better.

[NiteFalcon]

42 amp? LOLL

[Cathy]

and what ur cr is...

what baffles me is how u can get the stats in option 2? care to show a screenie? been under the impression that it's either 72 or 80 cd off of pc dmg (with 0 amp) or if u wanna go for one slot 14 amp with pc dmg, best u can get is 56 cd extended.

Or u happen to have a 2 slot pc dmg with amp in one slot? man, epic! then u only have 52 cd but 80 cd potential (which may never be realized due to the scarcity of sehh). screenshot pls or it doesn't exist lol.

this is forcium and not lycan, k.

For option 2 he added wrong, he meant 14 amp and 80 cd.

For option 1: 32 cd craft, 14 amp in 3 slots

For option 2: 32 cd craft, 48 cd in slots, 14 amp in 1 slot

He's basically asking is 14 amp or 24 cd better. I'll say amp.