Rate the Signature Above!

[Error]

-1 Sonic render is hard to see
-1 Overly blended, way too many effects going over him.
-1 Text, the bottom right and the actual 'Sonic'. I personally don't like the emboss/gloss/outline text.
-1 Random FX, too bright in one spot and more darker in another. Almost like a light source, except the bright is all over one half of the tag.
6/10

Same as I said last time ^
New siggy!~

Really nice, you've improved a lot.
8/10
-Your light source is just a big white negative space, try to stay away from that.
-Render seems awfully flat, hard to see much depth.
Also I feel that it's an overly bright tag...idk, maybe do some burning or try to bring out the contrast.

The line for your name could be reduced a little. Maybe do a clipping mask with a B&W gradient layer going like this and tweak the opacity/layer setting a bit.

[Sonic]

-1 Sonic render is hard to see
-1 Overly blended, way too many effects going over him.
-1 Text, the bottom right and the actual 'Sonic'. I personally don't like the emboss/gloss/outline text.
-1 Random FX, too bright in one spot and more darker in another. Almost like a light source, except the bright is all over one half of the tag.
6/10

WHAT!1!!!one!11!!
this is an outrage
you will hear from my lawyer sir

gagagaga

[YumCookies]

-
Really nice, you've improved a lot.
8/10
-Your light source is just a big white negative space, try to stay away from that.
-Render seems awfully flat, hard to see much depth.
Also I feel that it's an overly bright tag...idk, maybe do some burning or try to bring out the contrast.

The line for your name could be reduced a little. Maybe do a clipping mask with a B&W gradient layer going like this and tweak the opacity/layer setting a bit.

Haha thanks! Really?? I love the brightness of it! XD

@ERror
10/10
Really nothing else that could be done to it...everything looks solid already :P

[WIpwns]

10

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

Hmmm...
The heavy glow is a bit too much for me and just doesn't suit the background IMO. [Although I do <3 glow effects]
Too much empty space on the left side
Change the font color of that text! [It doesn't match well :P]
Overall, great work for just starting out :O
8/10

Please rate this one
Tried something different lol. First time doing a sig like this.

wait is that from Angel beats? coz that one from Angel Beats and Suzumiya haruhi both look alike =P
anyways for that one 8/10 (didnt like the water drop effect much)

as for ur own sig RITSU!!! 9/10 (9! moe kyun! hehehe)
-1 coz i feel like that one part was too bright. well i just dun like those too bright ones XD

[Sniper]

edit: forgot to rate reborns. 9/10 i like the depth

I made some new ones, trying to make them faster so they might not be that great of quality..


The first one I think is lol, my friend came up with the idea.






And this one is for Yum because I know she/he likes this kind of stuff.




Rates from everyone Weew

[YumCookies]

edit: forgot to rate reborns. 9/10 i like the depth

I made some new ones, trying to make them faster so they might not be that great of quality..


The first one I think is lol, my friend came up with the idea.






And this one is for Yum because I know she/he likes this kind of stuff.




Rates from everyone Weew

1st one:
I love the vectored look to it.
An easy 9.5/10

2nd one:
Wow that one is great! Nice blending, effects, etc. Just not too big of a fan on the text and the bottom left corner!
9/10

3rd one
Pshhh -.- I don't like the mosaic background and the random brush strokes :P
7.5/10

Reworked the lighting/ some depth with my sig.

Rate this one and the one I have right now please

[Sniper]

You finally added color 9.7/10



Damn so close that time.

[YumCookies]

You finally added color 9.7/10



Damn so close that time.

Oh right, forgot to tell you. Add more depth to the second one.


Reworked lighting/ depth issues. Any better?

[Sniper]

I have a really good idea for one that you will think is a 10/10 Yum! I seem to have trouble with text so i'll just leave it out. I'll hopefully have it finished tomarrow..



edit: i'm working on two now might only get 1 done though

Oh and as a heads up; you might want to bring an extra pair of pants.