Rate the Signature Above!

[Enigma]

8/10

Ehh, that's how I make my sigs, so the focus is more on the person/object rather than the text.

[WIpwns]

I like how it pops out more, but i can't see the text very well. sooo

7/10 for both.
11/12
;)

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

made a new siggy! my 4th one.. its just simple but hope u guys like it ^^

[inkeh]

A lot of room for improvement - starting with text and the background color. Maybe leave the bg with a normal color and minimal color effects? Not really sure but as of now, It kinda hurts my eyes to look at the background. Overall a pretty decent sig though.

6.7/10

[Flarius]

I think its just a little too dark around the P, maybe add a little inner glow to just the P and have the opacity ultra low to bring it out just a tad more. I like it though. 8/10

[inkeh]

SKIP RATING ON THIS POST

Lol actually wanted to make the text more transparent but that just makes it extremely hard to read. It's just a quick sig logo I made for PROJECT 52. =D

edit: I save all my .PSDs so I can just put the text on top and erase everything except for the rasterized P and play with the opacity and use my cloud brush eraser to adjust it - eitherway. But really too lazy to redo it since I'm working on other ones. XD

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

A lot of room for improvement - starting with text and the background color. Maybe leave the bg with a normal color and minimal color effects? Not really sure but as of now, It kinda hurts my eyes to look at the background. Overall a pretty decent sig though.

6.7/10

there i took off the rgb lighting. any better?
wanted to make it as simple but unique as possible XD

[inkeh]

A lot better XD

Ermm.. Try to play with blurring the background to create depth and maybe add some gradient maps (B/W + Blue/Orange + Pitting Curve?) and adjust the curve on an active merged layer (Ctrl+Alt+Shift+E). Then the rest is up to you.

PS: I'd also advise doing a light smudge on a low opacity duplicate of the focal layer to make the edges smoother to help with the blending.

Just some suggestions =p

[CyrStalAFX]

^_^

[Flarius]

A lot better XD

Ermm.. Try to play with blurring the background to create depth and maybe add some gradient maps (B/W + Blue/Orange + Pitting Curve?) and adjust the curve on an active merged layer (Ctrl+Alt+Shift+E). Then the rest is up to you.

PS: I'd also advise doing a light smudge on a low opacity duplicate of the focal layer to make the edges smoother to help with the blending.

Just some suggestions =p

Heh I was going to suggest adding a gradient onto it too. I think just a black and white one on overlay with about 25% opacity would do the trick. But always try new things. Save your sig on a .png file before you try fooling around so if you don't like what you did you don't have to start all over. The history only goes so far lol.

And crystal...Lol all I ever see you say is "^_^". =p

[oXIo]

there i took off the rgb lighting. any better?
wanted to make it as simple but unique as possible XD

blur the background with probably like 40% stregnth and then go layer -> gradient map and add them on in like 20 - 50% opacity until the colors blend fairly nice.

and flarius, 8.5/ 10
I like the concept of it, but it just doesn't seem right to me.

[Flarius]

Yeah was more of a try it out type thing...I gotta make myself another one sometime lol.

7/10 for yours, made me squint to find the name. >=[

[Enigma]

8/10


http://i40.tinypic.com/11qibk4.png

http://i42.tinypic.com/250m5af.png

Which one do you do prefer?

[inkeh]

v1 purple.

But tbh, I really think people should try going beyond the whole "C4d (color dodge) + Anime = cool sig" thing; or worse, the entire focal popping-out of a C4D spammed rectangle style. Experiment a bit more with text, effects, pentool and photo-manipulation.

[YumCookies]

7.5/10
I don't like how it looks like it's bad quality >_<

Made for a friend, rate please:
http://i42.tinypic.com/2vci8vq.jpg

[Error]

The white lighting make the dark monotone feel of the sig feel awkward. The C4D coming from the camera/light is iffy, idk why but makes the flow off imo. The render/focal seems flat, the text stands out too much. I can see some choppiness on the right side of the focal, ruins depth. The other effects seem nice, the circles are a bit too noticeable imo, detracts from the blur of the birds.
You're improving a lot, I like the effects but just needs work on making the focal stick out more and working on the text. Sorry if I'm too harsh or hard to understand, haha.

6.5/10 (I hardly rate 9's and 10's though, don't worry)

[YumCookies]

The white lighting make the dark monotone feel of the sig feel awkward. The C4D coming from the camera/light is iffy, idk why but makes the flow off imo. The render/focal seems flat, the text stands out too much. I can see some choppiness on the right side of the focal, ruins depth. The other effects seem nice, the circles are a bit too noticeable imo, detracts from the blur of the birds.
You're improving a lot, I like the effects but just needs work on making the focal stick out more and working on the text. Sorry if I'm too harsh or hard to understand, haha.

6.5/10 (I hardly rate 9's and 10's though, don't worry)

Any better? :o
http://i39.tinypic.com/28qz3av.png

[Error]

Any better? :o
http://i39.tinypic.com/28qz3av.png

Yep, much, much better. Lighting is more balanced and creates a nice feel. 8/10 :)

[Sniper]

I like Reborns, 7/10. It's creative in my opinion.

I like Errors also, but I have seen it somewhere before... 6.5/10.

Can you guys rate this one I made last night? It took me like a couple hours... :S
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/61754.jpg

[YumCookies]

I like Reborns, 7/10. It's creative in my opinion.

I like Errors also, but I have seen it somewhere before... 6.5/10.

Can you guys rate this one I made last night? It took me like a couple hours... :S
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/61754.jpg

Te c4d sticks out a little too much along with some of the smudging...and it doesn't blend too well IMO with no clear light source :x
But, much better than your previous work.
7/10

[Error]

I like Errors also, but I have seen it somewhere before... 6.5/10.

It's probably because I made this 2-3 years ago and I used similar text style in various other sigs of mine, and back then I was active around numerous forums.

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/61754.jpg
6/10
imo, the colors don't really click well together. work with using Gradient Layers and Photo Filters. Also, the text stands out quite a bit(not sure if that's intentional or not) and usually should not be in the corner of a tag. The blur is too high and obvious at the top of the sig. It should be toned down so it doesn't look unnatural. The white brushing or glow around the entire tag look strange to me. The C4D's around look messy imo. The things going around in the background looks interesting. Again, sorry if I'm a little harsh.

[Sniper]

It's probably because I made this 2-3 years ago and I used similar text style in various other sigs of mine, and back then I was active around numerous forums.

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/61754.jpg
6/10
imo, the colors don't really click well together. work with using Gradient Layers and Photo Filters. Also, the text stands out quite a bit(not sure if that's intentional or not) and usually should not be in the corner of a tag. The blur is too high and obvious at the top of the sig. It should be toned down so it doesn't look unnatural. The white brushing or glow around the entire tag look strange to me. The C4D's around look messy imo. The things going around in the background looks interesting. Again, sorry if I'm a little harsh.

It's cool, I just started. Well if you made that signature I should obviously have given it higher, haha..
But yeah the top left corner I messed up so bad I just colored over it because it was pretty late and I was sick of it...
However now that you say that it makes it look like garbage. Whatever i'll just work on another.


Te c4d sticks out a little too much along with some of the smudging...and it doesn't blend too well IMO with no clear light source :x
But, much better than your previous work.
7/10

I see.. I'll make another, gotta get that perfect ten...

[YumCookies]

5/10 for the army one still.

[Sniper]

Why don't you like it? I mean I knew putting it up, most people wouldn't like it for it's artistic flair. I'm working on a better avatar though, i'll have it up later tonight...

[YumCookies]

Why don't you like it? I mean I knew putting it up, most people wouldn't like it for it's artistic flair. I'm working on a better avatar though, i'll have it up later tonight...

Sorry to be blunt about this, but if you're not going to rate the sig above then don't post.
5/10
- The box on the right side stands out way too much
- It's just a wall of text
- Too lazy to read all of it

[Sniper]

I'm just starting, I didn't think you would want my opinion.

7/10, I don't like full black and white signatures, and it reminds me of Flarius's work. The girl doesn't stand out as much to me. I'm only half sure it would look better with more depth.

[Suzaku0]

Still 5/10 for me too. Walls of moving text aren't my thing. Also, it doesn't really flow. It's, blocky. It's like picture and then white spot. Nice try for starting out.

[cadacus_ater]

7/10. Neat word scrolling, but not my favorite image.
I tried my hand at Gimp to attempt combining 2 images (the character and the background) and tried as best I could to remove the original background of the character image, also playing with some lighting effects on the character. Tell me what you think. Pointers are welcome!
http://i43.tinypic.com/2w6drad.jpg

[Sniper]

Still 5/10 for me too. Walls of moving text aren't my thing. Also, it doesn't really flow. It's, blocky. It's like picture and then white spot. Nice try for starting out.

9/10(For your current signature) Suzaku, I like the way it fits with your gif. Can you rate my new one?
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/61754.jpg



7/10. Neat word scrolling, but not my favorite image.
I tried my hand at Gimp to attempt combining 2 images (the character and the background) and tried as best I could to remove the original background of the character image, also playing with some lighting effects on the character. Tell me what you think. Pointers are welcome!
http://i43.tinypic.com/2w6drad.jpg
6.8/10
I like the tree, I think it's pretty unique. It's better than your current one. You could blend it a little better.

[Suzaku0]

7/10. Neat word scrolling, but not my favorite image.
I tried my hand at Gimp to attempt combining 2 images (the character and the background) and tried as best I could to remove the original background of the character image, also playing with some lighting effects on the character. Tell me what you think. Pointers are welcome!
http://i43.tinypic.com/2w6drad.jpg

Hmm, I'm guessing it's your first time using Gimp? (Personally, I like Photoshop better but that's besides the point) Anyway...I'd give it a 6/10.
First off, the lightning on the head of the character is really strong; I can hardly make out the details that are there and it doesn't really flow with the lightsource from your background, (which looks like you just cropped and didn't do anything to it) And the text needs to be worked on as well. Just plopping it down on the background doesn't really cut it for me. If you need help with text effects in Gimp, there are plenty of tutorials out on the web somewhere. Now, as I am still learning myself, take my advice with a grain of salt; It's just my opinion.

:) Keep working at it.



9/10(For your current signature) Suzaku, I like the way it fits with your gif. Can you rate my new one?
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/61754.jpg

Sorry for the wall of text, but you guys just posted around the same time I did. Haha anyway.
I'd give it a 7/10.

It's a lot better than your current one, but for some reason, it just doesn't "pop" to me. Personally, with an image like that, I would have liked it to come out more. It seems to blend in with the background a bit too much. Nice try though.

[cadacus_ater]

Hmm, I'm guessing it's your first time using Gimp? (Personally, I like Photoshop better but that's besides the point) Anyway...I'd give it a 6/10.
First off, the lightning on the head of the character is really strong; I can hardly make out the details that are there and it doesn't really flow with the lightsource from your background, (which looks like you just cropped and didn't do anything to it) And the text needs to be worked on as well. Just plopping it down on the background doesn't really cut it for me. If you need help with text effects in Gimp, there are plenty of tutorials out on the web somewhere. Now, as I am still learning myself, take my advice with a grain of salt; It's just my opinion.

:) Keep working at it.

9.9/10 because I'm very hesitant to give things a direct 10. Love the image though. Yes, this is my first go at Gimp. Tried looking for photoshop a bit, but everything was either trial period or cost money (and saw less legal sources as too risky to my computer and personal information). As for the lighting, I had a hard time determining it from the background I used. I'll keep trying, and look for some of the text examples you mentioned.

[Suzaku0]

When I'm stuck on ideas for making siggy, this is one of the sites I use. Hopefully it can help you as much as it helped me. I linked it directly to the Gimp - Text effects.

http://www.pixel2life.com/tutorials/gimp/text_effects/

[Sniper]

Good luck with the text Cadacus.


These are just several backgrounds that I made, I plan on using it for my avatar. The second one is sharpened. What one looks better? And of course advice is cool, too. I was trying to make it sort of match my signature. Sorry if you guys don't like it. I don't like it for it's artistry or anything, but for what it is. And in the end, that's all that matters, right?


http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/cad_edited-1_256.jpg

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/cad_edited-2_256-2.jpg

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/cad_edited-2_256.jpg

[cadacus_ater]

I'm leaning toward the 1st background Sniper. For a general reference, here are the images combined, uncropped (except for the character's original background) and with no lighting changes. From what I see, the light source for the character would either be behind him, but very faint, or out of the picture (assuming something like street/park lights, it would probably come from above and left roughly). But this is just my amateur analysis. Ideas? (I love tinypic)
http://i41.tinypic.com/1zo9b1e.jpg

[GuardianPat]

Rate my new sig :D

http://i39.tinypic.com/34yv0wg.jpg

[Suzaku0]

:O Nice siggy. 9/10

[Sniper]

Rate my new sig :D

http://i39.tinypic.com/34yv0wg.jpg

7/10 Not rw3.

[Sniper]

I'm leaning toward the 1st background Sniper. For a general reference, here are the images combined, uncropped (except for the character's original background) and with no lighting changes. From what I see, the light source for the character would either be behind him, but very faint, or out of the picture (assuming something like street/park lights, it would probably come from above and left roughly). But this is just my amateur analysis. Ideas? (I love tinypic)
http://i41.tinypic.com/1zo9b1e.jpg

Maybe out of the picture from the bottom right. I think from the top left would make it mess up the tree, but i'm not a hundred percent sure.

[Suzaku0]

I'm leaning toward the 1st background Sniper. For a general reference, here are the images combined, uncropped (except for the character's original background) and with no lighting changes. From what I see, the light source for the character would either be behind him, but very faint, or out of the picture (assuming something like street/park lights, it would probably come from above and left roughly). But this is just my amateur analysis. Ideas? (I love tinypic)
http://i41.tinypic.com/1zo9b1e.jpg

Actually, I think it would be better if you just blend the images. Since you have the character positioned right there, the light source can come from the background itself. Try a gradient map and blend the images together.

[YumCookies]

8/10

[WIpwns]

8/10

[cadacus_ater]

8/10. Its a little too 'tall' for my taste and doesn't really grab my attention at first glance as far as theme goes. It does have some features that intrest me as I look longer at it, so that's why it gets 8 instead of 7 or 6.

I went ahead and did more modifying on my test project, and whether it is really much better or not I'll leave you to decide. The blending was the trickiest part for me, not sure if I did it the way I should, and as for the text, I took some pointers, but wasn't able to completely duplicate their finished product, so I played around til I got something I liked. Comment and rate as you please. I just know that I worked enough on editing everything that I can be happy displaying it as a sig.

[Suzaku0]

A lot more improved. i like it. Would be better if it was blended a bit more; the character and the background i mean. But all in all, good for your first time.

7/10.

[YumCookies]

@Cacadus
I don't really like the text TBH, it just looks a bit awkward-ish...not sure how to explain >_< But for one of your first times, it's great D:
8/10

Suzaku0
Now that I look at it a bit longer, I love the text like <3333333333 But...not to fond of how the character fits in :x
8.5/10

[Suzaku0]

:O What do you mean how the character fits in. o.O I'm all for suggestions.

[Sabuvok]

9/10 xP

[YumCookies]

:O What do you mean how the character fits in. o.O I'm all for suggestions.

Well actually it fits in perfectly and pleasing to the eyes, but I guess I'm just biased more toward images that don't take up 1/2 the sig xD

@Sabu:
8/10

[GuardianPat]

9/10 nice chick :P

[Sniper]

7/10
And for my latest work of art....

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/rr.jpg



I call it YumCookies.

[Flarius]

7/10
And for my latest work of art....

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/rr.jpg


I call it YumCookies.

Yummmm chocolate. 3/10

[Enigma]

8/10

Lol @ the turd.

[Sabuvok]

lol 8/10

[Sniper]

8/10

Lol @ the turd.

8/10 Enigma, I like it. It blends well.

[oXIo]

2/10

[Sabuvok]

7/10

[Enigma]

7/10

[Sniper]

6/10

2/10

I think you need to look at signatures in a different way, other than art.

[oXIo]

2/10

[Enigma]

8/10

[cadacus_ater]

8/10. I like and dislike the red lines at the same time. Look at it one way and I don't like the line positions, another way I think it's a neat idea. I think if there were one or two fewer red lines going along red portions of the character, particularly on the left arm, I'd like it a bit more. It does have a kind of style to it though.

[Enigma]

6/10

http://i39.tinypic.com/5yzymh.png

http://i39.tinypic.com/x1j4v5.png

Which looks better? Regular? Or charging?

[BlaneAkarui]

Charging!
lols I created ma sig just for this!

[YumCookies]

Ummmm 10/10

[Enigma]

8/10

[BlaneAkarui]

8/10
awesome my sig pwns i got a perfect score

[Sniper]

I can't give it a number out of ten, but i'll give it an A for effort.

[Sniper]

Sorry for the double post, I just made another one and need advice.
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/28429.png
Hope you guys like it..

[Enigma]

6/10

I like the image itself, but there are a lot of things are going on in that sig that I do not understand.

I see two light sources emanating from opposite corners that seem to be pointless.
I see a soft light brush scattered where arrows have hit which are not very pleasing to the eyes.\
Your text is too flashy.
There is a random line below your text that stretches across the whole sig.

http://i39.tinypic.com/5yzymh.png

http://i39.tinypic.com/x1j4v5.png

Which looks better? Regular? Or charging?
Rate too please.

[Sniper]

The text is a bit much i'll agree, but I didn't want to use Times, lol. But yeah anyway, the top black line and the bottom black line are something I put in to emphasize the signature, and leave my mark, too. Sort of like your cell phone bars. I sort of took your idea but used it differently...
7/10
Personally I like the charged. I mean, that's what it looks like he's doing.
I don't understand why the light source is on the bottom right, and "Atlas" looks a bit shaken up. Not sure what i'm seeing. Overall it's a good signature!

[oXIo]

The text is a bit much i'll agree, but I didn't want to use Times, lol. But yeah anyway, the top black line and the bottom black line are something I put in to emphasize the signature, and leave my mark, too. Sort of like your cell phone bars. I sort of took your idea but used it differently...
7/10
Personally I like the charged. I mean, that's what it looks like he's doing.
I don't understand why the light source is on the bottom right, and "Atlas" looks a bit shaken up. Not sure what i'm seeing. Overall it's a good signature!

@sniper
2/10

and uh enigma he's right. ur light source should be coming from the guns

[Sniper]

@sniper
2/10

and uh enigma he's right. ur light source should be coming from the guns
7.5/10
Is that for my current one, or the new one I made, oXIo?

[Enigma]

5/10

How's this?
I tried to fix it.

[Sniper]

It's better than before, but still a little dark imo. 8.5/10

[cadacus_ater]

Submitted for your appraisal, 2 variants on my current test work. Played around with some brushes to make a kind of 'aura' around the character and messed with text. I won't have much chance to mess with this next week, so it may be a while before you see any more changes.
Here's the first one...
http://i41.tinypic.com/2uojpf5.jpg
...and the second
http://i43.tinypic.com/18fc5w.jpg
Both are uncropped from the starting point, so they will likely be trimmed to my current sig's size. Please compare to my current if you can.

[Suzaku0]

I like your original one better. The other ones; the aura color doesn't really match and doesn't flow well.

5/10, 5/10

[oXIo]

7.5/10
Is that for my current one, or the new one I made, oXIo?

current
5/10 for ur new one

7/10 suzaku0
a bit to plain for me

[cadacus_ater]

8.5/10. I don't like the small text, but that's just me.

Ok so no aura. Is the text in the sig I use and the two I have shown pretty much a matter of preference? Cause I personally like the new text a bit better, was thinking of changing to that perhaps with different colors.

[BackUpMENG]

0/10 ugly bromengski

[Error]

10/10

[cadacus_ater]

9/10


0/10 ugly bromengski

No comment.

[Suzaku0]

The new text does look nicer in a sense but i'd rate it about the same as your original one.

[Enigma]

7/10

[cadacus_ater]

8/10

Ok last edit for a while. Switched the text to my proposed one and made a brief attempt to improve the blend, but it probably didn't do much.

[BackUpMENG]

8/10

Ok last edit for a while. Switched the text to my proposed one and made a brief attempt to improve the blend, but it probably didn't do much.

0/10
still ugly

[Renken]

4/10

kinda amusing =P

[YumCookies]

6/10
Creepy :x

[Salmarnirrrr]

9/10

Cool effects, hot chick. :P

[Sniper]

current
5/10 for ur new oneCan I get some constructive criticism with that? Here it is again so you don't have to scroll. I tried to make it not boring.

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/28429.png

[cadacus_ater]

6/10 for the arrows sig. Don't like how the background masks the last letter of your text and I'm not sure if i like the dots or not.

Ok someone besides BackUpMENG rate mine please. Also, if you have any suggestions for effects I might add when I get the chance (fog, lighting, lines, etc.) I'd love to hear some ideas.

@BackUpMENG: Sorry my taste and amatuer projects ruin your eyes. Honestly, I don't much like yours either. You just bore me all around. That is all I have to say to you.

[Sniper]

I dislike your font. Sorry I don't have any suggested ones though, not sure what would fit... Other than that I think it's a decent signature.

[WIpwns]

8/10

[Sniper]

Weeeew thanks. 7.5/10

[Enigma]

5/10

http://i40.tinypic.com/1zd6ate.png

Inspired by the guy above lol.

[YumCookies]

Light source is waaaay to awkward, try using a lens flare instead of a brush for it :p
c4d just doesn't fit in IMO >.<
8/10

[Rayfui]

The Panda Pawns all > : D

[Sniper]

5/10

http://i40.tinypic.com/1zd6ate.png

Inspired by the guy above lol.

Nice! I love the background, but the sniper itself could use a little work. I personally don't think the light soruce is akward.

9/10



Okay yeah I made this one in like ten minutes(PhotoBucket edits :x) I know it's ty and it isn't even a signature but, trying to get all the practice I can get. Rate and constructively criticize please.
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/Decorated%20images/SeamenRec.png

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

A lot better XD

Ermm.. Try to play with blurring the background to create depth and maybe add some gradient maps (B/W + Blue/Orange + Pitting Curve?) and adjust the curve on an active merged layer (Ctrl+Alt+Shift+E). Then the rest is up to you.

PS: I'd also advise doing a light smudge on a low opacity duplicate of the focal layer to make the edges smoother to help with the blending.

Just some suggestions =p


ok edited my current sig,this is what it was before..
http://i164.photobucket.com/albums/u1/erickrayos/SigProto3.png

and the finished one is under there


=P

[Suzaku0]

ooooo me likey 9/10
Much better than before. :)

[Flarius]

You sure like your flower brushes don't you. lol 7/10

Rate this one.
http://i292.photobucket.com/albums/mm4/1337Flarius/rayfui.png

[inkeh]

I'll hit it with a solid 9/10 if you edited the skull + hoodie into looking like a panda.

6/10 if not.

[WIpwns]

0/0

[inkeh]

Trying to take a shot at my balls because I denied your request or is it just frustration and jealousy? :p

Why do you even keep posting in this thread when you didn't make those sigs? Oh, kids. :rolleyes:

Anyway, I'm feeling nice so I decided to just take on your previous request and make you a sig.

Hope you like it ^^
http://i43.tinypic.com/2bb6kl.jpg

[WIpwns]

0/100

[inkeh]

Lol. butthurt and jealous much? =)

(Still need some CnC on my latest tag. Ignore the attention-deprived child .)

[WIpwns]

00000000000000000000000000%

[inkeh]

Lol. Keep it up.

It only enforces your image as a jealous, talentless, 13-year-old interweb buff who does nothing else but play cabal =)

rty's that tough on you?

Anyway, I'll just go ahead and keep doing what I've been doing all along - ignoring your BS.

PS. I'd feel pretty ty myself as well if my parents named me Janry.

[Enigma]

8/10

I really like the concept and art of the tag, but...

-1 for the those abstract things coming from the guy's head. I don't think those particular ones flow with the sig very well.
-1 because I don't like sigs that take up too much room lol.

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

8/10, the clarity of the main image isnt that clear to me, or maybe that was intentional? making it look like distorted due to the railguns? =P

[YumCookies]

-1 because the girl doesn't blend too well with the background
9/10
Interesting concept, me likey :)

[Sniper]

8/10
@Reborn
9/10 For the current one, 10/10 for the one with the regular colors.

[Sonic]

10/10
for what i believe is a gun in the mouth

-1 for religious quote!

9/10

[cadacus_ater]

9/10. Loses one because I'm trying not to let my childhood Sonic craze bias me. Just kidding. I'm reluctant to give it 10 though, in part due to text, not sure what I'd do to change it. It's pretty good.

[YumCookies]

9/10. Loses one because I'm trying not to let my childhood Sonic craze bias me. Just kidding. I'm reluctant to give it 10 though, in part due to text, not sure what I'd do to change it. It's pretty good.

-1 not too fond of the text >_<
-1 Don't really like how that guy is placed with such a colorful background [like there's no blending or anything ._.]
8/10

[WIpwns]

10

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

@sonic 8/10 (-2 for the spiderman font on the lower left corner)
@cadacus 6/10 things seems not right on it T_T
@yum 9/10 (-1 coz i feel like theres too many things going on in that sig T_T)

[turtle1337]

10 cause i like anime :D

[Enso]

10 cause i like anime :D

8 because it's cool but cliche. o.O

[YumCookies]

8 because it's cool but cliche. o.O

-1 font not to my liking :p
-1 because you made the giant black spiral thing your focal point (not very pleasing to the eyes)
-1 background looks like it's stock :x
7/10

[rythemz]

7/10

I like the one that you made yourself before =/

[YumCookies]

7/10

I like the one that you made yourself before =/

Huh o.o I made this one by myself, and the link is the one Enigma made me :)

-1 Shouldn't have lens flared there T_T
9/10

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

Huh o.o I made this one by myself, and the link is the one Enigma made me :)

-1 Shouldn't have lens flared there T_T
9/10

+1
@rythemz

as yum said. the lens flair on the speaker isnt necessary =P

[Error]

+1
@rythemz

as yum said. the lens flair on the speaker isnt necessary =P

Interesting concept, I rather preferred the other version. This stands to me as a 6/10 but 7/10 because it's interesting to see other types of tags other than the standard "C4D/Brush/Grunge"

-1 The RGB thing going on in the back makes the focal stand out, but make it look like it doesn't belong.
-1 Along those lines, it really looks like "Background > Filter > Text > Render > Icon > Save." I don't mean offense towards you however.
-1 The icon seems a little bland and there's some white stuff on the right.
-1 The font and text stick out too much. Though that's probably what you're aiming for, it doesn't feel like it belongs due to how it isn't quite blended in well imo.

[Flarius]

FA looks hot. 10/10 >=D

[WIpwns]

0/10
i dont play with toys

[YumCookies]

-1 Because too much pink :< [First sig]
-1 Sort of blurry on the wiz pic
8/10

-1 Because me didn't really like colors :x
9/10

Overall score:
-.5 being too big
8/10

Please rate this one ^_^
http://i39.tinypic.com/105una1.png

[WIpwns]

-1 me thinks tis too bright
9/10

[Useless]

10/10 cause it's my ;)

[WIpwns]

10/10 cause it's my ;)

0/10 its too small and i cant read font

[Useless]

Blah my mistake i didn't set it right

[cadacus_ater]

7/10 Light seems a bit akward to me, but I'm learning light is a pain to deal with, lol. So is font.

Speaking of font, any suggestions on what mine should be? Like should it be cursive, script-like, bold, italicised, blocky...whatever. Trying to get an idea of what atributes the font should have, and also, if I should go for some differnent effects or a different color for the text.

I'm still playing around with the blending, but its mostly just that so far...playing. I'm trying to get a feel of the way things affect the images and gain a sense of what a good blend would look like in general. I'll try to post a couple revisions as far as blending goes when I have some to ask about and have critiqued.

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

Interesting concept, I rather preferred the other version. This stands to me as a 6/10 but 7/10 because it's interesting to see other types of tags other than the standard "C4D/Brush/Grunge"

-1 The RGB thing going on in the back makes the focal stand out, but make it look like it doesn't belong.
-1 Along those lines, it really looks like "Background > Filter > Text > Render > Icon > Save." I don't mean offense towards you however.
-1 The icon seems a little bland and there's some white stuff on the right.
-1 The font and text stick out too much. Though that's probably what you're aiming for, it doesn't feel like it belongs due to how it isn't quite blended in well imo.



your right about the font. im new to using photoshop and still dunno the go arounds on it. i wanted the font to look like a graffiti on that wall, i wanted to make it look like its originally there on the background but im still newb T_T, dunno how to make it look like it belongs to the original pic.

[Sonic]

-1 too big for me !
-1 does that say hercury? i cant tell lol
+1 for uniqueness
9/10

do the one yum yum made i like the colors o.o
http://i46.tinypic.com/2hrjzas.png

[YumCookies]

your right about the font. im new to using photoshop and still dunno the go arounds on it. i wanted the font to look like a graffiti on that wall, i wanted to make it look like its originally there on the background but im still newb T_T, dunno how to make it look like it belongs to the original pic.

About 3-6 gradient maps and photo filters and put put on different blending modes! Experiment! This takes me like 30min - 1hr >_<

EDIT:
-1 because the character is too small :(
<3 The colors too :D
9/10

For the sonic one:
-1 Text doesn't look nice :<
-1 Text in the bottom right same thing :<
+1 because me likey abstract ^_^
9/10

Please rate this one :)
Tried something different lol. First time doing a sig like this.
http://i40.tinypic.com/4smyj5.png

[Sniper]

8/10 for it. It's awesome and if I liked just regular gray signatures it would be a 10/10. The background is sweet, I might add...


Can you guys rate this new one?

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/64948.jpg
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/crosshairgreen_edited-1.jpg

Different color crosshairs would be new avatar.

[YumCookies]

8/10 for it. It's awesome and if I liked just regular gray signatures it would be a 10/10. The background is sweet, I might add...


Can you guys rate this new one?

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/64948.jpg

Hmmm...
The heavy glow is a bit too much for me and just doesn't suit the background IMO. [Although I do <3 glow effects]
Too much empty space on the left side
Change the font color of that text! [It doesn't match well :P]
Overall, great work for just starting out :O
8/10

Please rate this one :)
Tried something different lol. First time doing a sig like this.
http://i40.tinypic.com/4smyj5.png

[WIpwns]

-1 ewww
9/10

10/10 if colored

[YumCookies]

Same as I said last time :D ^
New siggy!~
http://i39.tinypic.com/el6zqu.png

[Sonic]

-1 me no likey the black rim
-1 it makes me curious in a angry bad way
+1 dual wielding wands ftw O.O

9/10

[Sniper]

7/10, Shadow > Sonic

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/64948.jpg

Can I get more rates please?

[Sonic]

shadow can burn in the hell!

but um

-1 for the color pallet in the bottom left
-1 i dont like the text
-1 i think its too empty
+1 it has a lot of potential, like maybe make the glowing illuminate a dim room! o.o

8/10

[Error]

-1 Sonic render is hard to see
-1 Overly blended, way too many effects going over him.
-1 Text, the bottom right and the actual 'Sonic'. I personally don't like the emboss/gloss/outline text.
-1 Random FX, too bright in one spot and more darker in another. Almost like a light source, except the bright is all over one half of the tag.
6/10


Same as I said last time :D ^
New siggy!~
http://i39.tinypic.com/el6zqu.png

Really nice, you've improved a lot.
8/10
-Your light source is just a big white negative space, try to stay away from that.
-Render seems awfully flat, hard to see much depth.
Also I feel that it's an overly bright tag...idk, maybe do some burning or try to bring out the contrast.

The line for your name could be reduced a little. Maybe do a clipping mask with a B&W gradient layer going like this and tweak the opacity/layer setting a bit.

[Sonic]

-1 Sonic render is hard to see
-1 Overly blended, way too many effects going over him.
-1 Text, the bottom right and the actual 'Sonic'. I personally don't like the emboss/gloss/outline text.
-1 Random FX, too bright in one spot and more darker in another. Almost like a light source, except the bright is all over one half of the tag.
6/10

WHAT!1!!!one!11!!
this is an outrage
you will hear from my lawyer sir

gagagaga

[YumCookies]

-
Really nice, you've improved a lot.
8/10
-Your light source is just a big white negative space, try to stay away from that.
-Render seems awfully flat, hard to see much depth.
Also I feel that it's an overly bright tag...idk, maybe do some burning or try to bring out the contrast.

The line for your name could be reduced a little. Maybe do a clipping mask with a B&W gradient layer going like this and tweak the opacity/layer setting a bit.

Haha thanks! Really?? I love the brightness of it! XD

@ERror
10/10
Really nothing else that could be done to it...everything looks solid already :P

[WIpwns]

10

[RebornSAZUZAKI]

Hmmm...
The heavy glow is a bit too much for me and just doesn't suit the background IMO. [Although I do <3 glow effects]
Too much empty space on the left side
Change the font color of that text! [It doesn't match well :P]
Overall, great work for just starting out :O
8/10

Please rate this one :)
Tried something different lol. First time doing a sig like this.
http://i40.tinypic.com/4smyj5.png


wait is that from Angel beats? coz that one from Angel Beats and Suzumiya haruhi both look alike =P
anyways for that one 8/10 (didnt like the water drop effect much)

as for ur own sig RITSU!!! 9/10 (9! moe kyun! hehehe)
-1 coz i feel like that one part was too bright. well i just dun like those too bright ones XD

[Sniper]

edit: forgot to rate reborns. 9/10 i like the depth

I made some new ones, trying to make them faster so they might not be that great of quality..


The first one I think is lol, my friend came up with the idea.
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/113.jpg


http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/112.jpg


And this one is for Yum because I know she/he likes this kind of stuff.
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/114.jpg



Rates from everyone Weew

[YumCookies]

edit: forgot to rate reborns. 9/10 i like the depth

I made some new ones, trying to make them faster so they might not be that great of quality..


The first one I think is lol, my friend came up with the idea.
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/113.jpg


http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/112.jpg


And this one is for Yum because I know she/he likes this kind of stuff.
http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/114.jpg



Rates from everyone Weew

1st one:
I love the vectored look to it.
An easy 9.5/10

2nd one:
Wow that one is great! Nice blending, effects, etc. Just not too big of a fan on the text and the bottom left corner!
9/10

3rd one
Pshhh -.- I don't like the mosaic background and the random brush strokes :P
7.5/10

Reworked the lighting/ some depth with my sig.
http://i39.tinypic.com/2qd5zf7.png
Rate this one and the one I have right now please :)

[Sniper]

You finally added color :D 9.7/10



Damn so close that time.

[YumCookies]

You finally added color :D 9.7/10



Damn so close that time.

Oh right, forgot to tell you. Add more depth to the second one. :D


Reworked lighting/ depth issues. Any better?
http://i39.tinypic.com/2qd5zf7.png

[Sniper]

I have a really good idea for one that you will think is a 10/10 Yum! I seem to have trouble with text so i'll just leave it out. I'll hopefully have it finished tomarrow..



edit: i'm working on two now might only get 1 done though

Oh and as a heads up; you might want to bring an extra pair of pants.

[Enigma]

5/10

http://i42.tinypic.com/72379f.png

http://i39.tinypic.com/1zxmfc0.png

Which do you prefer?

[YumCookies]

5/10

http://i42.tinypic.com/72379f.png

http://i39.tinypic.com/1zxmfc0.png

Which do you prefer?

Top one.
10/10

[cadacus_ater]

@YumCookies: 8.5/10. Its good, but something about it is weird to me. Might just be the character artwork isn't my favorite.

@Enigma:
I'd give them both 8/10. The text is too small for me to read. As far as which I prefer, I like them for different aspects, but in general, I shy away from the stain.

Went back to the blending and text detail and came up with these two attempts. Please rate, and tell me which you prefer (and why if possible). I'm still open to suggestions on how to improve.
http://i39.tinypic.com/mh7te0.jpg

http://i44.tinypic.com/2h85wnt.jpg

[Enigma]

@Enigma:
I'd give them both 8/10. The text is too small for me to read. As far as which I prefer, I like them for different aspects, but in general, I shy away from the stain.

Went back to the blending and text detail and came up with these two attempts. Please rate, and tell me which you prefer (and why if possible). I'm still open to suggestions on how to improve.
http://i39.tinypic.com/mh7te0.jpg

http://i44.tinypic.com/2h85wnt.jpg
6/10

7/10

I like the bottom one more because the text's color matches the color scheme of the sig better.

And about my new sig...
The text is purposely small. It adds a style to text that isn't boring like the average, same sized, same color font that some people use.

[cadacus_ater]

9/10 to you then.

http://i39.tinypic.com/mh7te0.jpg

http://i44.tinypic.com/2h85wnt.jpg

If you can, please try to comment on the blend too, as well as the text and/or font. Wondering if I should do some burning, gradients, bluring, lightening, darkening, etc. Been wondering if I should try to add a foreground element of some kind.

[Enigma]

Same ratings.

I don't like your sig much because there doesn't seem to be much focus on the character itself. You might as well have a landscape sig.
There's also a depth problem in your sig. It looks flat.
The text looks ridiculously large in comparison to the rest of the sig.
I'm a total noob at gradient mapping, blending, and lighting so I'm not going to comment on that.

[cadacus_ater]

(See rating in previous post)

Hmm, you raise some good points...thanks for the input. I'll see what I can do.

[WIpwns]

7/10 too big kakaka

[Enigma]

n/a

[WIpwns]

10/10 me likey kakakkaa

[YumCookies]

N/A

New siggy to rate
http://i42.tinypic.com/wbz8uh.png

[inkeh]

5.5/10

Text is way too plain and the effects don't really seem to flow together. Kind of like a step back from the progress I've seen lately. The sig is just a bit too bland.

[CyrStalAFX]

rate ^_^ http://img268.imageshack.us/img268/8445/freelance.png (http://img268.imageshack.us/i/freelance.png/)

[Enigma]

You know you're supposed to rate the sig above yours as courtesy for a rate on your sig.

No rating.

@inkeh
7/10

Sorry, I just don't like it

[YumCookies]

5.5/10

Text is way too plain and the effects don't really seem to flow together. Kind of like a step back from the progress I've seen lately. The sig is just a bit too bland.

Hmmm I still have the full colored version of that one, but I kind of liked the feel to the dulled one down better xD. I'll post it later when I get home and tell me of it's better ya? :D

Cyrstalafx: 8/10
The firework things stand out too much to me, but it's colorful ^_^

Enigma:
10/10

Inkeh:
8.5/10
The bottom right seems to be off a little...or that might just be me...nice smudging .
:)

[cadacus_ater]

Still 8.5/10.
Ok if these effects aren't working for the image, let me know. If they could work, should they be a different color? Went ahead and shrank the text and cropped the sigs a bit vertically.
http://i44.tinypic.com/2co0lms.jpg

http://i44.tinypic.com/10xhrae.jpg

[YumCookies]

N/A

New siggy to rate
http://i42.tinypic.com/wbz8uh.png

Need more ratings for this!~
@Cactus
TBH, I really cannot think of a single font that would go nicley with that sig since it's basically just a landscape sig...no depth >.>

[CyrStalAFX]

^_^

[Flarius]

Your name just seems so weird to me lol. You should try and find a full render of her, and resize her so nothing gets cut off, that would look good.

6.5/10


Yumcookies: 7/10, render doesn't seem like it fits to me.

[Sniper]

7/10



Alright I made two new ones, but this should be the ten i've wanted... RATE D:<


http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/10.png
I think it's one of my best ones so far.

[WIpwns]

0/10 for not having lethalkakakkaka in the sig

[Enigma]

7/10



Alright I made two new ones, but this should be the ten i've wanted... RATE D:<


http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/10.png
I think it's one of my best ones so far.

8/10

-1 for color theme
-1 for the level of depth
-1 for looking boring
+1 for effort and concept

[YumCookies]

Same rating. <3 T.O.P.

http://i40.tinypic.com/sq10sn.jpg
Fixed this up a bit...rate both this one and the one down there V

[Sniper]

@Yum
8/10 For the top, it's boring

9/10 For your current one, I like the layout.


8/10

-1 for color theme
-1 for the level of depth
-1 for looking boring
+1 for effort and concept
Looking boring??? I'm crushed...
If you guys think it's that then this will be my last one for a bit, until I can find something that strikes me as incredibly vivid.

http://i977.photobucket.com/albums/ae259/Album_00/sasuke.png

[Assimilation]

Top: Dull, bland, boring, and just scattered all over the place. Try to have a better sense of flow and possibly fill those spaces dulled out on the right and left edges; looks terrible with them just "faded" out. Also, again, colors. Don't just set your render/focal to one solid color, lolol. Work around it's colors or make small changes. Anyways, 5/10.

[Sniper]

1/10, You're a ing hypocrite. You wanna talk dull? Check your own signature. Go GETSOME tutorials.

Top: Dull, bland, boring, and just scattered all over the place. Try to have a better sense of flow and possibly fill those spaces dulled out on the right and left edges; looks terrible with them just "faded" out. Also, again, colors. Don't just set your render/focal to one solid color, lolol. Work around it's colors or make small changes. Anyways, 5/10.

Edit: I just raged out hard, i'll ignore everything you just typed because i'm sure you don't know as much as you should.

[Assimilation]

Broski, that's nothing compared to what I can do. Also, yes, I know a lot. Do you have a degree in Graphic Design? No? I didn't think so. QQ moar, son.

[Sniper]

Broski, that's nothing compared to what I can do. Also, yes, I know a lot. Do you have a degree in Graphic Design? No? I didn't think so. QQ moar, son.

Sounds like you mad bro, show me some of your work.
I'm not old enough to graduate from High School yet, but i'm sure the letters G,E, and D won't be on my diploma. At least not one after another.

If i'm going to chat fight you you're going to have to change your signature; it's two colors, has no flow, and it's making my eyes bleed.

[Assimilation]

http://i143.photobucket.com/albums/r125/_Dist/WIP4.png

http://i143.photobucket.com/albums/r125/_Dist/Chaos.png

http://i143.photobucket.com/albums/r125/_Dist/BlueSamus.png

http://i143.photobucket.com/albums/r125/_Dist/Halo.png

http://i143.photobucket.com/albums/r125/_Dist/Cloud.png

Would you like more and LOLUMAD? Also, I do have my GED. Doesn't make me any less intelligent than you, bud. Already finished 2 years of Graphic Design and 1 year of Computer Electronics and Engineering Technology.

[Sniper]

Read what you told me to do, and then look at what you've made. Your images are a cluster of boring .

Hope you remember what Loit said to you.

Yo UR SIG UGLY MANG U HANDICAP GOT 1 ARM? KAKAKAKAKAAKAKAKAKAK DUMB WELFARE BLACK



Oh and; LOL YOU HAVE YOUR GED? LOL YOU'RE ING STUPID LOLOLOLOL.
That's my last post for the day, don't take it too seriously, or you might jump off a cliff.

[Assimilation]

Read what you told me to do, and then look at what you've made. Your images are a cluster of boring .



Oh and; LOL YOU HAVE YOUR GED? LOL YOU'RE ING STUPID LOLOLOLOL.
That's my last post for the day, don't take it too seriously, or you might jump off a cliff.

LOL. 4.0 GPA dropped out Senior year due to boredom and wanting to go to College sooner. LOLOLOL.

3rd and 4th ones are realism, kid. Get some. They're simplistic and the renders aren't part of those backgrounds.

[Sniper]

LOL. 4.0 GPA dropped out Senior year due to boredom and wanting to go to College sooner. LOLOLOL.

3rd and 4th ones are realism, kid. Get some. They're simplistic and the renders aren't part of those backgrounds.

Sorry for calling you out like this, but it's just so obvious.


If your 4.0 GPA existed, you would have done earley descision. You wouldn't have wasted four years of perfect work for a GED and then go to a ty college that would have half the experience of a semi-decent one. Besides, who in their right minds would ascertain a ing GED when they have a couple months left of school and a perfect 4.0?



Check your first sentence, I think a 4.0 student would realize that the grammar is horribly wrong.

[Suzaku0]

Hey. I thought this thread was made for rating signatures, not raging at each other. And with rating, comes criticism; If you can't handle it. You shouldn't be posting.

[inkeh]

Try not to use this thread as a stage for your "measuring contest."

This community is already plagued enough by the whole anime/asian+C4D obsession so try not to add one more thing that slams this "artist" community to the bottom of my list.

[YumCookies]

@Sniper

Hmmmm...I liked the robot one better :x
Not really a big fan of the colors, but I do like the lightning effect. When Assimilation says "A sense of flow," it means that the image doesn't come together right. If you look at the right hand side, you'll see the lightning coming what looks like downwards, when the flow from his hand should be going upwards - if not then you should just remove the lightning on the right side. There's also a mass of negative space on the bottom right hand corner where it's just blank :x
But, I can tell that the depth is fairly nice judging from the bottom left hand corner and overall a fairly solid looking thing [except for some scattering/ flow issues].
8/10

@Inkeh

Rated already

@Assimilation

Not a big fan of the inversion of colors in there along with the spatter :x Just a little plain looking to me.
7.5/10

@Suzaku0

Rated already

Rate my 2 sigs please ^_^

http://i40.tinypic.com/sq10sn.jpg

And the one I have right now \/

[Enigma]

8.5/10

So I tried something new... I despise it.
http://i40.tinypic.com/14scfbb.png
Rate this and the the one below please. V

[YumCookies]

8.5/10

So I tried something new... I despise it.
http://i40.tinypic.com/14scfbb.png
Rate this and the the one below please. V

6/10
Just not very eye appealing...and it's creepy :x

New sig to rate!
http://i41.tinypic.com/2627ewl.png

[YoungForum]

6/10
Just not very eye appealing...and it's creepy :x

New sig to rate!
http://i41.tinypic.com/2627ewl.png

8/10 yummy Cookies makes me hungry -_-

[YumCookies]

^ You're sig is too small! Make sure you use Insert Direct Link Here instead of the forum uploader!
Not rating since too small to judge >_<

New sig to rate!
http://i41.tinypic.com/2627ewl.png

[YoungForum]

^ You're sig is too small! Make sure you use Insert Direct Link Here instead of the forum uploader!
Not rating since too small to judge >_<

New sig to rate!
http://i41.tinypic.com/2627ewl.png

Thats wat she said -_-

[Trouvo]

itty bitty siggy

[Enigma]

@Trouvo
6/10


thats wat she said -_-

LOL

[YumCookies]

@Trouvo
6/10



LOL

^ Rated already D:
http://i41.tinypic.com/6q8fug.png

Rate rate rate ^

[Flarius]

Hot hot hot, would be nice with a little boarder! 8.5/10

[YumCookies]

^ Rated already

Bordered version:
http://i41.tinypic.com/33tikk0.png

[CyrStalAFX]

^_^

[Error]

^ Rated already D:
http://i41.tinypic.com/6q8fug.png

Rate rate rate ^

At first it looks pretty nice. When I look again, it looks pretty flat imo. The smudge is a nice thing but it doesn't have much depth, not saying it has none but it's not much.
The lighting is in the wrong place, assuming your light source is that pale orb or the white negative space to the right. The render's light is coming from the top left.
Splatter is a little sharp in some places (like near the back of her hair and bottom left of her arm/chest)

Imo, it lacks noticeable FX. Border version doesn't help (seriously, borders are overrated and detract from a tag, especially a black on bright)
6/10

[BackUpMENG]

At first it looks pretty nice. When I look again, it looks pretty flat imo. The smudge is a nice thing but it doesn't have much depth, not saying it has none but it's not much.
The lighting is in the wrong place, assuming your light source is that pale orb or the white negative space to the right. The render's light is coming from the top left.
Splatter is a little sharp in some places (like near the back of her hair and bottom left of her arm/chest)

Imo, it lacks noticeable FX. Border version doesn't help (seriously, borders are overrated and detract from a tag, especially a black on bright)
6/10

roled

[EliteDragon17]

Pls rate the one I made in 10 mins D:

[CyrStalAFX]

4/10 too small
^_^

[EliteDragon17]

Too lazy to change the size lol

P.S: 9.5/10

Very nice design to it and the background flows well with the pic. IMO, a different font colour would be nice. ><

[YumCookies]

You're sig is too small!! Fix ittt!
/denied rating D:

@Cyrstal
Wow that's really good o_o Everything goes well nicely. I really don't know how you could improve it except for the random lines going through his head...they seem to not belong. Well anyways, solid looking sig for me.
9.8/10

@Error, ah I see now :D Is this any better? :)
http://i43.tinypic.com/2628n12.png

[Error]

http://i43.tinypic.com/2628n12.png

Tbh, it's not much better. Light source is too far from the render and barely adds any effect to it. 6/10

The first version has a nicer array of colors, this newer one seems to have flatish colors. (Try to use burn tool!)
And for your lighting are you using the filter? Try to use some brushes (doesn't have to be white! possibly a light bright color like a light pink or light blue for example) and set those to overlay or color/linear dodge with opacity reduced. To make the lighting more real, use black brushes but lower opacity and possibly do overlay/soft light to bring out a nice contrast(like the left side, it looked pretty nice before).
Haha, sorry if I'm confusing you or anything. :p

@CyrStal: 7/10 It's interesting but honestly it looks like you did a lot of airbrushing and clogs up the depth. Could use some more colors and a definite lighting source.

[BackUpMENG]

lol

[YumCookies]

I'm just using a smudged white cloud. :\

[EliteDragon17]

You're sig is too small!! Fix ittt!
/denied rating D:

The file is too big D: (40.4 kb)

Your sig:

9/10

The blur in the top-right is a bit distracting, but the rest fits together nicely =)

[CyrStalAFX]

^_^

[YumCookies]

^ Rated already

Andddd moreeee reworkinggggg
http://i44.tinypic.com/una04.png

[Enigma]

9/10!

http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/128/6/f/Jessica_by_Elementi_kun.png

http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/128/5/9/Roger_Federer_by_Elementi_kun.png

[Flarius]

I like the second one, looks like you screwed up on the first one a little.

5/10
9/10

[Enigma]

7/10

Where did I mess up?

[Flarius]

9/10!

http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/128/6/f/Jessica_by_Elementi_kun.png


It would look better without the second render in there. Part of the effect at her waist is also cut off. You could always just crop out that side of the sig, you don't want to have to be figuring out how to fill it up.

[YumCookies]

8.5/10 ^
Everything looks nice but I think it's missing something...just can't place a finger of what though...

Random work. lol
http://i42.tinypic.com/25rph0x.png

Need more rates on this one too:
http://i44.tinypic.com/una04.png

[CyrStalAFX]

^_^

[WIpwns]

8.5/10 ^
Everything looks nice but I think it's missing something...just can't place a finger of what though...

Random work. lol
http://i42.tinypic.com/25rph0x.png

Need more rates on this one too:
http://i44.tinypic.com/una04.png
9/10
8.5/10

^_^
8/10

[Enigma]

n/a

Need more rates for this:
http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/128/5/9/Roger_Federer_by_Elementi_kun.png

[WIpwns]

n/a

Need more rates for this:
http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/128/5/9/Roger_Federer_by_Elementi_kun.png
9/10
-1 i cant read anything below "The Maestro"

[YumCookies]

9/10
-1 i cant read anything below "The Maestro"

It's suppose to be like that :P It gives it some style xD

Took me around 3 1/2 hours to do this one... please rate :)
http://i44.tinypic.com/r93bpv.png

version 2:
http://i41.tinypic.com/6nuzyx.png

[WIpwns]

It's suppose to be like that :P It gives it some style xD

Took me around 3 1/2 hours to do this one... please rate :)
http://i44.tinypic.com/r93bpv.png
10/10
version 2:
http://i41.tinypic.com/6nuzyx.png
9/10
idk why but somethings wrong o.o

[Hatsuho]

1st one 9.5/10
2nd one 8/10

-> took 35 mins lol http://i696.photobucket.com/albums/vv323/SweetOtaku/hatsuho2.png

[Enigma]

7/10

Still want more rates on this:
http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/128/5/9/Roger_Federer_by_Elementi_kun.png

[CyrStalAFX]

^_^

[WIpwns]

7/10

Still want more rates on this:
http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/128/5/9/Roger_Federer_by_Elementi_kun.png
already rated urs

^_^
same on u =D

[YumCookies]

already rated urs

same on u =D

6/10
Don't like the left side at all along with the text TBH.
7.5/10
Don't like it in general because of the colors/ effects used.

Made for a friend
http://i44.tinypic.com/mljpsn.png

Need more rates on these
http://i44.tinypic.com/r93bpv.png

version 2:
http://i41.tinypic.com/6nuzyx.png

[Enigma]

7.5/10
I like the concept, but I don't really like the text or the blandness

8/10
Love Haruhi, but that pic isn't very good. I also don't like the text or the background much.

7/10
Same as the one above except the sig is worse than just being bright. It's bright but there also isn't much color.

Still want more on:
http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/128/5/9/Roger_Federer_by_Elementi_kun.png

[YumCookies]

9.5

New sig
http://i43.tinypic.com/124afjc.png

[WIpwns]

9.5

New sig
http://i43.tinypic.com/124afjc.png

10/10
i like the lightning effect

[Enigma]

6/10
8/10 (biased :D)

http://i43.tinypic.com/167o6xs.png

[WIpwns]

7/10
lightning behind too fat xD

[Enigma]

Same ratings.

Too fat? It's mother ****ing Thor

http://bookhound.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/thor-standing.jpg

But I digress.

Anyways, still want more rates for:
http://i43.tinypic.com/167o6xs.png

[YumCookies]

8/10
The lightning looks weird!!! [Not saying you should remove it though.]

New siggy
http://i44.tinypic.com/106ndcj.jpg

[CyrStalAFX]

^_^ thank you yum!

[YumCookies]

^_^ thank you yum!

Bottom left looks a bit off, text is kinda weird. 8.5/10

Made some vertical sigs :x Which one looks the best?
http://i41.tinypic.com/246qiy1.png

http://i40.tinypic.com/2ujjh8x.jpg

http://i41.tinypic.com/167312b.jpg

[CyrStalAFX]

i fix ^_^

[TheKing]

LOL THANKS ALOT CrystalAfX for the sig!!!
Woot woot!

[Assimilation]

Pretty beast; I was never good at those pop-out style sigs, lol. I never really got them to work for me. My only main complaint is the text is really hard to read. Might just be me, though.

[elviento]

8 just cause is mayhem

[TheKing]

5 coz it's kinda I love you >.<♥I love you >.<♥I love you >.<♥? Lol peace!

[YumCookies]

7/10
Not too fond of the blending or the text >.<

Need rates on these :/

http://i44.tinypic.com/106ndcj.jpg

http://i41.tinypic.com/246qiy1.png http://i40.tinypic.com/2ujjh8x.jpg http://i41.tinypic.com/167312b.jpg

[Assimilation]

8/10
7/10.

First one:
Wow, lol. That's pretty awesome broski. Only thing I could say is maybe give it a touch more of blue on it.

Second one:
Black/white = best, but I'd like to see something... more to it. Maybe some more effects?

[elviento]

QQ leave my 16 sehh alone >..> they for proofs

[Assimilation]

http://i143.photobucket.com/albums/r125/_Dist/GodOfWar-2.png

http://i143.photobucket.com/albums/r125/_Dist/GodOfWar2.png

Two new ones... Well, the same one with 2 versions, lol.

[SilentM]

I HAVE to bother you about your actual signature. I feel like the render is misplaced with the background. It almost looks like a random anime character was shopped into a realistic photo of a New York subway. The little sparkles are are also way out of place and everything about the sig feels very dull. There's nothing that captures the eyes, and nothing that adds any type of flow or appealing effect. I don't know why you like black and white so much baby. Take your hand off the desaturate option. :P

On the other hand, the signatures posted have much better flow and render placement, not to mention better combination of different elements. The colored version of the signature is better, although the black and white version can still hold its own. Maybe you should change the text to say Mayhem and use it as your new sig lol. It would work!

[Nanjirou]

Wheres ur sig foooooooooo

[SilentM]

Wheres ur sig foooooooooo

Lol I cant decide what type of sig I want yet so I'm too lazy to get one!!! Where's yours?

[Nanjirou]

Rate please ^_~

Omg idk how to show my sigx_x

[Nanjirou]

Hahahaha Double post ftw Sig is up!

[WIpwns]

Hahahaha Double post ftw Sig is up!

0/10 u dam prono star

[Nanjirou]

9/10

I dont see no <love>

[WIpwns]

9/10

I dont see no <love>]
I love you >.<♥I love you >.<♥I love you >.<♥I love you >.<♥ u